This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

On Sunday mornings, there’s nothing I’d rather do than fire up the coffeepot, beach myself next to my partner on the couch, and watch the previous night’s SNL. (I realize this is cringe, and I do not care.) That’s what I did yesterday morning, and it’s a good thing I was in full recline when this segment came on or I’d have fallen OUT: 

I immediately scurried to post it in the group chat with my fellow middle-aged ride-or-dies, but I was too late: The clip was already making the rounds among my girlfriends, earning vigorous affirmations and emojis and choruses of OMGGGGG SO MUCH SAME. I guess there are just a lot of women who can relate to taking care of an older relative despite having brothers capable of sharing the load…??!

The elder care product fake-advertised in the satirical ad from last night’s show is called Sister™. It’s exactly what it sounds like: a younger female family member who upends her life to care for an aging parent because the men in the family won’t. 

How does it work? It’s simple, as a fake doctor explains: “First, years of internalized sexism warps Sister™’s brain into thinking caregiving is her responsibility and somehow, not yours.”

It’s always a delight when the most trenchant observations about a big social problem come from comedians. And indeed, the segment nailed this and some other important problems in family caregiving. Three in five family caregivers in the US are women, and the caregiver gender gap has historically been starkest between siblings. In a 2017 study, daughters gave their aging parents about twice as many hours of care as sons. Other studies suggest they also provided more routine care that involved a broader range of tasks. 

Why family caregiving often falls on women

Why do women take on more caregiving burdens? Part of the reason is money. Women still earn less than men on average, and a household’s lower earner tends to take on more of the family care. 

But that’s just one half of a vicious cycle: Being the relative who shows up carries what experts call a “care penalty.” 

One aspect of that penalty is the financial disadvantage family caregivers suffer because their work is often uncompensated or poorly paid. Nearly half of caregivers in the AARP–NAC survey reported at least one major financial hit, like taking on debt, stopping saving, or being unable to afford food. Caregivers reportedly spent an average of $11,500 a year on caregiving expenses.

But caregiving also reduces the time a person can spend climbing a career ladder and increasing their earning potential. A 2011 report estimated that women who leave the workforce early to care for a parent lose about $143,000 in wages — about 60% more than men — and $131,000 in Social Security benefits, plus pension losses. A more recent Department of Labor estimate that also considered child caregiving put the wage losses closer to $43,000.

The ad got this right, too. It promises no applications or insurance forms: “Simply text ‘dad fell’ to Sister,” the voiceover says, “and she will quit her job, break her lease, and move halfway across the country to take care of him.” Hilarious! And true.

Caregiving also comes with emotional and physical costs. Women caregivers report more depression and worse physical health than men who are caregivers. When researchers account for the heavier loads women carry and the thinner support they get, most of that gap goes away. The problem isn't hormones; it’s workload. 

What would help?

A few policy changes would help make caregiving less of a Lady Problem. 

In the US, leaving work to become a caregiver usually means losing your income, your job, or both. A national paid leave program would change that equation, and unlike most wealthy nations, the US doesn’t have one.

Social Security could stop penalizing caregiving. Under current rules, years out of work to care for someone count as zero earnings. Germany and several other countries give caregivers pension credits for that time, and Congressional bills have proposed doing the same here.

The government could take on more of the cost of paying for long-term care so families aren't the default system. (Medicare doesn't cover it, and Medicaid usually kicks in only after people spend down almost everything they have.) America’s first state long-term care insurance program in Washington State began paying benefits this year; the rest of us have to find something on the private market, which is increasingly challenging.

I can relate

Over the last couple of years, I’ve become a lot more involved in making decisions related to the care of my brother, who has an intellectual disability and requires round-the-clock care. And in the last couple of months, the health and mobility of another family member has declined quite a bit, and I’ve had to step in to help. (Forgive the vagueness; it’s out of respect for their right to confidentiality.)

I’ve been stunned by how big a toll these obligations have taken on my productivity in other areas of my life. I never saw myself as a caregiver and never particularly wanted this role, but there’s literally nobody else in my nuclear family who can do these things. 

I’ve also been really saddened by how much this role reveals about the people whose lives are tied up with others’ health. The moments where Sister™ gets rude comments about her appearance from the person she cares for and takes on the bogeyman role for both her dad and her weaselly brother are depressingly familiar.

There’s an old saying that tragedy plus time equals comedy. But if you’re ok laughing through tears, you can still enjoy a joke about bad things that are happening right now.

I love it when readers tell me who they are and what they want! Fill out my reader survey to get more of what you want Landmansplained.

Are you a family caregiver? Want to talk to me about what’s hard about the job? Email me at [email protected], fill out this form, or find me on Signal at kerenlandman.07.

Like what you see here? Subscribe, and feel free to share this with someone else you think might like it.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate